West Side Story (2021)

When I first heard that Spielberg’s first-ever musical, something he’s hinted at for decades, would be a remake of the near-perfect, 10-Oscar winning West Side Story, I imagined my review would begin with this line from the lyrics of its key song— “We'll find a way of forgiving.”

Well, I was wrong. There’s a place for this. Turns out, we need both the perfect and 1961 film and a new one.

It should have been a lose-lose idea. Staying close to the 10-Oscar winning classic could be too corny. Redoing it; blasphemy. But Spielberg’s vision worked in all the right places while keeping the perfect tone.

He also did the unthinkable. The climactic, signature song “Somewhere” is no longer sung by the lead couple. Instead, EGOT winner Rita Moreno, in a new role (Valentina), does. Moreno, who won an Oscar for the original, adds new depth and layers to the song making it more moving and profound. The first Latina Oscar winner delivers lines such as “there’s a place for us” with extra heft and meaning with her quiet, powerful voice. It is not a cameo. It is the heart of the film.

Baby Driver star Ansel Elgort (Tony) initially seemed somewhat inferior seen side by side with Broadway singers and dancers, but eventually won me over. In today’s enlightened, media-savvy world, it’s most important that the role delivers on the earnest naivety of a young man who would do anything for a first love. I believed it.

Juliet to his Romeo, Rachel Ann Zegler, a YouTuber discovered in a search for this role, lights up the screen and is dazzling. And Arian DeBose (Hamilton) has the unenviable task of appearing onscreen with Moreno in the role she’s famous for, Anita. She rocks it. Simply put, the full cast of performers is A+mazing.

It is an all-star production not to be missed. Take Leonard Bernstein’s music and Stephen Sondheim’s lyrics, add this generation's most rounded A-list director (Schindlers List, ET), a script by Tony Kushner (Angels in America, Munich, Lincoln), dazzling, swooping, wide-scoped choreography by visionary Justin Peck, this cast, and Leapin’ Lizards! you have one of the best films of any year.

In a nutshell: Something good. Spielberg’s musical debut pulls off the impossible; it’s a can’t miss film.

Award potential: A front runner for all the top categories. If Moreno is nominated, she’ll be the first to do so twice for the same film title.

Where to see it: In theaters. I recommend IMAX or the largest screen near you.

The Ten Buck Review: Worth ten bucks.