While some of the best movie biopics have come from actors who don’t exactly resemble their subjects, the idea of the slender, emo Timothée Chalamet channeling Bob Dylan seemed, at least on paper, a bit off. I’m sure I’m not alone in my curiosity, though it might not be entirely fair to Chalamet.
After watching A Complete Unknown, I can confidently say that Timothée Chalamet mostly pulls off the young Bob Dylan vibe—about 89.5% of the time. When he's singing or simply gazing into the camera, he nails it. It's almost uncanny how much he channels the elusive, poetic energy of Dylan. But, and this is where things get a little tricky, those moments of physicality, when the character is alone with their thoughts, like riding off into the distance on a motorcycle. In these quieter, unspoken scenes, where movement is all we have to read, you start to notice the wig a bit too much. Suddenly, it feels less like Dylan and more like Pee-wee Herman on a bicycle. It’s a little jarring, but hey, the other 88% of the time? Total magic.
So is the director, James Mangold who is gold when it comes to films like the Johnny Cash rock biopic Walk the Line, Ford V Ferrari and Logan, the best comic book film there is. Mangold certainly knows how to create chemistry onstage whether it's a duet (Dylan and Joan Baez, June and Johnny Cash) or an iconic solo performance.
And the cast gets every note right too. Elle Fanning takes on the role of Sylvie Russo, a character clearly inspired by the free-spirited Suze Rotolo—though, for reasons only the producers of Dylan himself might fully understand, she gets a new name. The film plays like a companion piece to her own biopic, My Freewheelin’ Time, offering a glimpse of the real, sometimes uncool, and decidedly human Bob Dylan—stripping away the legend to reveal the guy we rarely get to see.
Ed Norton, portraying Pete Seeger, is the emotional heart of the film. Yes, you read that right. In a surprising departure from his usual roles and own personality, Norton steps into the shoes of the earnest, deeply empathetic friend—becoming the film's soulful center. Director James Mangold doesn't attempt to explain Bob Dylan; instead, the film offers a perspective on him from the outside, seen through the eyes of those around him—particularly Seeger, Russo, and Baez.
Purists and die-hard fans may feel a bit of whiplash from the creative liberties taken with song placements at key concerts and moments in Dylan's life. Rumor has it that Dylan himself insisted on several fake additions as well, the prankster he is.
Based on the book Dylan Goes Electric!, by Elijah Wald, this film is more than just a biopic; it’s a snapshot of a moment when the world began to realize Bob Dylan was more than a musician. It's a great film to sink into and enjoy this season with your fave folks.
In a nutshell: Dylan gets the Walk the Line treatment and Chalamet is electric.
Where to watch it: In theaters, starting December 25.
Would it be better with Oliva Colman? Of course it would
Award potential: Good news for red carpet fans. Chalamet should score or win at SAG and Oscars, however, he'll always be up against the fact that he'll be there again. Time will tell if this performance is too powerful to deny him more acclaim now.
The Ten Buck Review: Worth ten bucks.